By In Baseball, History, Joe Vault


Stan Musial never got thrown out of a game. Never. Think about this for a moment. Musial played in 3,026 games in his career, or about as many as his contemporaries Joe DiMaggio and Johnny Pesky played combined. He played across different American eras — he played in the big leagues before bombs fell on Pearl Harbor, and he retired a few weeks before Kennedy was shot. He played when Jimmy Dorsey and Glenn Miller ruled the Top 40 charts, and he played when Elvis was thin, and he played when Chubby Checker twisted. He played before television, and after John Glenn orbited the earth. And he never once got thrown out of a baseball game

There was this game, early in ’54, the year that Edward Murrow went after Joe McCarthy and Roger Bannister ran a mile in four minutes, and Musial’s Cardinals trailed the Chicago Cubs 3-0 in the seventh inning. Cubs lefty pitcher Paul Minner was baffling the Cardinals — he had allowed just two singles, had faced one over the minimum. Then he found himself facing Musial with Wally Moon was on first base and two outs.

Interlude: Wally Moon. One of the great 1950s baseball names of all time, right? The 1950s had a Wally Moon and a Wally Post and a Wally Westlake and even a Wally Moses. Only later, did baseball add Wally Bunker. Their cup runneth over.
Musial crushed a ball to deep right field, a double. Moon ran all the around the bases to score. Musial cruised into second. The whole complexion of the game had changed. And it was only then that everyone seemed to notice the first base umpire, Lee Ballanfant, was holding up his arms. He had called Musial’s double a foul ball.
Nobody quite knew how to react. The ball, at least in the Cardinals’ view, had clearly been fair. It was not even an especially close call. And while the crowd cheered wildly (the game was in Chicago) the guys on the Cardinals bench went crazy. They rushed on the field, shortstop Solly Hemus first, manager Eddie Stanky right behind him, and both were thrown out by home plate umpire Augie Donatelli. Old Augie Donatelli. He would play a big role in Musial’s life. Donatelli would be one of the umpires there less than a month later when Musial hit five homers in a doubleheader. Much later, he was behind the plate for Musial’s 3,000th hit. Anyway, he was here now, taking away a Musial hit, throwing out Hemus and Stanky, threatening pinch hitter Peanuts Lowrey with ejection, clearing the saloon like an old cowboy, even though, he certainly knew, the ball had been fair.
Musial, who in the confusion had not been told exactly what was going on, walked over to Donatelli. Then, according to the stories, he calmly asked, “What happened Augie? It didn’t count, huh?” Augie nodded sadly and said the umpire had called the ball foul.
“Well,” Musial said, “there’s nothing you can do about it.”
Stan Musial stepped back promptly doubled to precisely the same spot in right field. This time, Ballanfant called the ball fair. The Cardinals scored six runs in the inning and won the game.
The story has been told many times, in many ways, by many people, most famously by umpire Tom Gorman. He did not remember it quite right — he would say it had happened against Brooklyn, in ‘52, and he had been behind the plate. He obviously was confusing this story with another, but that’s really not hard to figure. Stan Musial had a lot of beautiful moments. There are a lot of stories. “Stan,” Tom Gorman said often, “is in a class by himself.”
* * *
Stan Musial grew up in Donora, Pa., during the Depression. They were a family of eight in a five-room house. In Donora, the smoke and fumes from the zinc factory mushroomed so thick and poisonous that no vegetation could grow on the hill. That barren, brown hillside was a constant reminder that the air was killing them. Stan’s father, a Polish immigrant, worked in that factory and, not too many years after Stan started playing ball, died from the fumes.
A tough childhood might not explain everything. Still, there was something about Stan Musial that did not let him forget Donora, did not allow him to change — “I’m so lucky,” he used to say every day, more than once every day, so many times that people would roll their eyes. But that seems to be how he felt, ever day, lucky.
Harry Caray, who of course first gained his fame calling Cardinals games on KMOX, would tell the story of a beaten down Musial going hitless in a Sunday doubleheader. The heat was unbearable that day — hell could not be much hotter than a St. Louis summer day — and after the game Musial walked gingerly to his car. He looked beaten down. He looked beat up. Musial never seemed to think of baseball as a job, but a daytime doubleheader in St. Louis might have made him think twice about it.
“Watch this,” Caray said to a friend as they watched the scene, and sure enough when Musial got to the car, there were a hundred kids waiting for him an autograph. Stan leaned against his hot car and signed every one.
Musial. People like to say that people have changed. I don’t see that exactly. The world has changed. Technology has changed. Movie and ticket prices have changed. Gas prices have changed. Many of the rules have changed — the reserve clause is gone, Title IX is in place, they let people swear on cable TV, airplanes and restaurants won’t let you smoke and you can no longer hold your infant in your lap in the front seat of your car. But people? I don’t know. I get a little queasy when I hear old time ballplayers talk about how none of them would have used performance enhancing drugs, and a little queasier when I hear old-time politicians talk about how they always reached across the aisle. You will still hear a lot of people romanticizing America in the 1950s. Those people tend to look a lot alike.
Still, it’s probably fair to say that there was something unique about the time that produced Stan Musial. Maybe in those days people treasured something they used to go by names like “class” or “grace” or “elegance” or some other highfalutin word. Maybe in that time they expected their singers to be dressed in tuxedoes, they wore ties and hats to go to the ballgame, they admired strong and silent types. Maybe they liked football players who did not celebrate their own touchdowns or boxers who spoke quietly, maybe they wanted their children to believe in a world where baseball players drank milk and said “golly” and married their high school sweetheart. It seems to me that the quintessential hero today is Josh Hamilton, left-handed power, supremely gifted, fallen from grace, back from the depths, crushing home runs and driving in runners while covered in tattoos that represent a time he regrets. That’s a story for our time, a story about a lost soul redeemed, and it touches our 21st Century hearts.
Musial is from his time. He smoked under stairwells to be certain that no kid saw him doing it. Friends say he drank privately, and very little, Stan the Man could not allow anyone to see him at less than his best. He often said his biggest regret was that he did not go to college. And, yes, he married Lil, his high school sweetheart, on his 19th birthday, almost 70 years ago.
He wanted to be a role model. He seemed to need to feel like he was giving kids someone to respect. That, as much as anything, drove him. Teammates had a standing wager on how many times he would use the word “Wonderful” in any given day. They usually guessed low. He was terrified of making speeches (this, friends say, is why he started playing the harmonica in public — so he could avoid actually speaking) and yet he almost never turned down a speaking engagement. He played in great pain, but nobody ever caught him running half-speed. When he felt like his skills had diminished, he asked for and received a pay cut.
Joe Black used to tell a story — he was pitching against the Cardinals, and as usual the taunts were racial. “Don’t worry Stan,” someone in the Cardinals dugout shouted, “with that dark background on the mound you shouldn’t have any problem hitting the ball. Musial kicked at the dirt, spat, and faced Black like he had not heard anything. But after the game, Black was in the clubhouse, and suddenly he looked up and there was Stan Musial. “I’m sorry that happened,” Musial whispered. “But don’t you worry about it. You’re a great pitcher. You will win a lot of games.”
Chuck Connors, the Rifleman, used to tell a story — he was a struggling hitter for the Chicago Cubs in 1951. He asked teammates what he should do. They all told him the same thing: The only guy who can save you is Musial. So Connors went to Musial and asked for his help. Musial spent 30 minutes at the cage with an opposing player. “I was a bum of a hitter just not cut out for the majors,” Connors said. “But I will never forget Stan’s kindness. When he was finished watching me cut away at the ball, Stan slapped me on the back and told me to keep swinging.”
Ed Mickelson only got 37 at-bats in the Big Leagues, but he has a story too. Musial invited him to dinner — he was always doing that stuff — and there Mickelson explained that he felt so nervous playing ball, that he could hardly perform. Musial leaned over and said quietly, “Me too, kid. Me too. When you stop feeling nervous, it’s time to quit.”
Well, there are countless stories like that, stories about Musial’s common decency and the way he could make anyone around him feel like he was worth a million bucks.
“Musial treated me like I was the Pope,” Mickelson said, and he was still in awe more than 50 years later.
* * *
These were the emotions Musial inspired in his time. He was so beloved in New York that the Mets held a “Stan Musial Day.” In Chicago, he once finished first in a “favorite player” poll among Cubs fans, edging out Ernie Banks. Bill Clinton and Brooks Robinson, growing up about an hour apart in Arkansas, were inspired by him.
Of course, it was mostly the playing. Stan Musial banged out 3,630 hits even though he missed a year for the war. He hit .331 for his career, banged 1,377 extra base hits (only Hank Aaron and Barry Bonds have hit more), stretched out more than 900 doubles and triples (only Tris Speaker has more) and played in 24 All-Star Games. He had that quirky and unforgettable swing, that peek-a-boo stance, and he probably inspired more famous quotes by pitchers than any other hitter.
Preacher Roe (on how to pitch Musial): “I throw him four wide ones and try to pick him off first base.”
Carl Erskine (on how to pitch Musial): “I’ve had pretty good success with Stan by throwing him best pitch and backing up third.”
Warren Spahn: “Once he timed your fastball, your infielders were in jeopardy.”
Don Newcombe: “I could have rolled the ball up there to Musial, and he would have pulled out a golf club and hit it out.”
And so on. Maybe pitchers felt in awe because there seemed no way to pitch him, no weaknesses in swing, fastballs up, curveballs away, forkballs in the dirt, he hit them all. In 1948, he had his most famous season, his season for the ages, .376 average, 46 doubles, 18 triples, 39 home runs, 135 runs, 131 RBIs. And yet, the thing about Musial, is that for more than 20 years he was pretty much always like that. Four other times he hit better than .350. Four other times he hit more than 46 doubles. He hit double digit triples eight times in all, he hit 30-plus homers five times, he walked more than twice as often as he struck out.
I suspect Musial can never be reflected in numbers because his resume is so all encompassing — it’s like Bob Costas said, he never hit in 56 straight games, and he did not hit 500 home runs (never hit 40 in a season), and he did not get 4,000 hits, and he did not hit .400 in any year. He was, instead, present, always, seventeen times in the Top 5 in batting average, sixteen times in the Top 5 in on-base percentage, thirteen times in the Top 5 in slugging percentage, nine times the league leader in runs created. To me, the best description of Musial through his stats is to say that 16 times in his career Musial hit 30 or more doubles. It might not make for a great movie. But all his baseball life Stan Musial hit baseballs into gaps and he ran hard out of the box.
* * *
Here’s the thing: A lot of baseball fans have forgotten Stan Musial. Anyway, it seems like that. It has been better the last few years, aided in part by George Vecsey’s fine book on Musial. Still, it’s striking how rarely his name is rarely mentioned when people talk about the greatest living players.  A few years ago, when baseball was picking its All Century team, Stan Musial did not even receive enough votes to be listed among the Top 10 outfielders. The Top 10.
True, he did not play in New York like the baseball icons, like Ruth and DiMaggio and Mantle and Koufax and Mays. True, he did not break the home run record like Aaron, he did not get banished from the game like Rose, he did not break barriers like Jackie, he did not swear colorfully like Ted, he did not hit three homers in a World Series game like Reggie, he did not glare like Gibson, he did not throw like Clemente and he did not say funny things like Yogi.
No, Musial just played hard and lived decently. He hit five home runs in a doubleheader, and had five hits on five swings in a game. He hit line drives right back at pitchers and then would go to the dugout after the game to make sure those pitchers were all right. He wasn’t perfect, of course, but he didn’t see the harm in letting people believe in something.
And maybe that sort of understated greatness isn’t meant to be shouted from the rooftops. Maybe Musial is just meant to be quietly appreciated. Every so often, even now, you can read an obituary somewhere in American’s heartland, and you will read about someone who “loved Stan Musial.” Everyone so often you will meet someone about 55 or 60 years old name Stan, and you will know why.

21 Responses to Musial

  1. JB says:

    Thanks for re-posting this, Joe. As a St. Louis native who loves Stan Musial but isn’t quite old enough to know why, I really appreciate this.

  2. Edward Gohl says:

    This comment has been removed by the author.

  3. David in NYC says:

    Thanks, Joe, for reprinting this. It’s one of my favorites of yours.

    When I first started paying serious attention to baseball at the age of 6, my hero was Mickey Mantle. That’s not very surprising, given that I lived in the NYC metro area and the Dodgers and Giants had already left town (and there would be no Mets for another 5 years).

    But, of all the players not named Mickey Mantle, my favorite was Stan The Man. Obviously, he was an extremely good baseball player, but there was just something about him that was different and made him special — so much so that I convinced my parents to take me to a Mets-Cards doubleheader at the Polo Grounds just so I could see him. Of course, he did not disappoint: in his last AB in game 2, he hit a HR; the next day, he homered in his first 3 ABs, making him one of a very small group of players who have hit HRs in 4 consecutive ABs. I didn’t see the whole thing, but I at least saw part of it.

    And, as a stats geek from way back, he owns one of my favorite stats of all-time — of his 3,630 career hits, he had 1,815 at home, and 1,815 on the road. Stan could (and did) hit anywhere.

  4. Ankit Desai says:

    Joe, this is the kind of writing that you need to get back to… It’s been missing of late.

  5. Grulg says:

    Great write up of a great man.

    • David says:

      All I know about Stan Musial is something I read in a book.

      A Brooklyn Dodgers player came up to him before a game and said, “Better watch out for me today, Stan. I woke up today feeling like a million bucks. Had a great meal just the way I like it. Then I knocked the ball all over the park in batting practice. I feel three hits today, Stan. You ever feel like that?”

      “Every day,” said Musial.

      And that just floored me. What couldn’t a man do if he felt that way every day?

  6. Kansas City says:

    I met Stan one time in an airport. He seemed like the nicest man I’ve even met. It was in the 1970’s.

  7. Llarry says:

    Joe, hopefully someday you’ll get the go-ahead to write the Musial biography that needs to be written.

    Of course, the same thing that makes us want to read about him is what makes him not want it written…

  8. bibliotrope says:

    One September night in 1963, my dad came home from work and asked me if I wanted to go to the ballgame. It was a twi-night doubleheader at Forbes Field, the Pirates were hosting the Cardinals. And Stan Musial from Donora was making his last visit as a ballplayer to the city just a few miles down the Monongahela River from his hometown. Even though he played for St. Louis, Pittsburghers, especially those of us from the Mon Valley, counted him as one of our own.

    And my dad wanted me to be able to say I saw Musial play.

    To be truthful, I don’t remember Musial’s role in those games well, though I remember people cheering for him. I was transfixed, as always, with Clemente. And I marvelled at Bob Gibson, who won one of those games. (I believe Bob Veale won the other, to split the doubleheader.)

    Also, another Nov. 21ster that you mentioned, Dick (“Ducky”) Schofield, was also playing that night, at shortstop for the Bucs.

    (Many years later, as my memory of that night faded and after my dad passed away, I began to wonder why did he take me to the ballgame on a school night? So I looked it up — it was a Friday, so no school the next day.)

  9. Unknown says:

    Thanks for re-posting this Joe. November 21st is my birthday too, your post is a great present to me.

  10. Rob Smith says:

    Musial was great, but even though I’m not close to young, he retired before I was old enough to pay attention. I think that’s the issue. You have to be pretty old to have seen him play, even at the end of his career… and I don’t recall any old highlight reels like with a lot of old players. Garagiola used to go on and on about him when he was announcing the Baseball Game of the Week…. but he hasn’t been on the air in what? 25 years? So, props to a great player!! I wish I could have seen him play.

  11. Rob Smith says:

    Just looked it up…. .417 life time OBP, .976 OPS and 123 WAR. Wow! Lifetime! Weird thing, he played more than 154 games 3 times. How did that happen? I guess there must have been a playoff of some sort.

  12. Rob Smith says:

    Another thing, I usually think of Musial as an outfielder, particularly right field. But he played over 1,000 games at 1st base and many games in left and center. And he didn’t just switch to first when he got older. He had seasons when he was young where it appears that he was the every day first baseman and then the next year, he plays mostly outfield. Interesting. -9.3 dWar, though, so I guess they had to put him some place.

  13. David in NYC says:

    @Rob Smith — Games suspended because of weather or darkness were replayed as brand-new games, but the stats from the suspended game (if it was official, i.e., more than 5 innings) still counted.

  14. Scott says:

    “You will still hear a lot of people romanticizing America in the 1950s. Those people tend to look a lot alike.”

    Why do you have to insert a plainly bigoted comment in an otherwise beautiful post?

  15. sreed24 says:

    Scott, I don’t think bigoted means what you think it means.

  16. This is a nice story. thanks for shearing.


  17. […] lastly, a link: Joe Posnanski on Musial, which may at least partly explain why Stan received a record share of support this […]

  18. Michael Thomason says:

    Frank “Pig” House was a friend and a soft spoken Southern gentleman who patiently answered all of my youthful questions about his time in the Majors. He spent most of his career with the Tigers but caught for the Cincinnati Reds one season where he played against Musial and the Cardinals. He told me that Stan hit more balls “dead flush” than any batter he had ever seen. And Frank had played against all those great Yankee teams, in addition to Teddy Ballgame in Boston. Speaking of the Yankees, I once asked him about Mickey Mantle and he replied, “One hundred and ninety pounds of muscle on a steel frame.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *