LeBron’s Hat …
Posted: October 12th, 2007 | Filed under: Cleveland, Essays | 27 Comments »
This is a brutally long blog about my history as a Cleveland sports fan. It is self-absorbed, certainly, and I wouldn’t blame you one bit if you skipped over it. But it’s also thousands of words (footnotes and all), and I have to do something with it. (I have added a few footnotes to clarify some of the Cleveland heartbreaks).
* * *
Things have changed in Cleveland. Things have changed all over. When I was kid growing up in on the East side — in South Euclid, if you want to be specific, home of Steve Stone (1980 Cy Young Winner), David S. Ward (director of Major League) and Eric Carmen (Hungry Eyes) — I’m pretty sure it was in the city ordinance that any locally born minor caught rooting for a team outside the city limits was to be fined and, on second offense, publicly caned. I suspect it was like this all over.(1) You rooted for your hometown teams or else, hell, there was no or else, no other option, you rooted for your hometown team because that was how it was.
Now, of course, it’s different, a topic which has been analyzed by us sports old-timers much in the same way sociologists have analyzed the development and modernization of the Kondh tribe. Kids root for whoever the heck they want to root for now, we have decided, because they have access to all the teams, free agency has changed the landscape (leagues, especially the Major Leagues, are set up more to root for individual players rather than teams), America has become more homogenized, etc. It also could be that there’s no loyalty left in the damn world.
All of this might explain how LeBron James, who grew up in Akron (which is just South of Cleveland) became a fan of the New York Yankees (which is nowhere near Akron, either geographically or emotionally) and therefore felt the need to wear a Yankees hat to the Indians-Yankees playoff game.
But I could not care less WHY he wore the Yankees hat (an Akron kid who grows up to be a Yankees fan defies explanation) as why it had such an enormous effect on Cleveland sports fans. I’m really wondering why the heck it ticked me off. Who really cares what teams LeBron James roots for? He’s a brilliant basketball player. He carried — in every possible way that verb can be used — the Cleveland Cavaliers to their first NBA Finals last year. He’s a Cleveland hero. What possible difference does it make if publicly roots for the Yankees or Dallas Cowboys or practices voodoo in his home or believes, deep down, that the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame should have been put in Detroit? Who cares?
I care. It flat ticked me off. And when I tried to come to grips with this, I realize that I have hard time coming up with a sensible reason why it ticked me off. It’s not logic, I guess. It’s emotion.
I read a letter to the editor from some Boston transplant who could not understand the fuss over LeBron — he wrote that Tom Brady was seen wearing a Yankees hat, and after a brief uproar, things quickly died down in New England. People even laughed about it. That nutty Tom Brady. “What difference does it make anyway?†the Boston guy asks. “We hate the Yankees more anyway.â€
But he can’t understand that Cleveland and Boston fans are just different, just as Philadelphia and Pittsburgh fans are different, or San Diego and San Francisco fans, New York Mets and New York Yankees fans. Tom Brady isn’t from Boston. He doesn’t stand for the same things.
The feeling we felt about LeBron — or at least the feeling I felt — wasn’t anger or hatred or even betrayal. It was more like this red-hot disappointment. He knows us. He knows what it has been like. He knows how many times his hometown sports teams have crashed to the ground the last 40 years. And he wore a freaking Yankees hat to the freaking game.
* * *
Cleveland Municipal Stadium, as we used to call it (all three words) had its own smell. All stadiums have their own swirl of scents, of course, popcorn, stale beer, sweat, cut grass, chewed gum, old shoes. Cleveland Municipal Stadium had all those, but it also featured a mystery smell, a constantly-shifting fragrance that sometimes burned the eyes like chlorine and in the next moment smelled sickly sweet, like burnt cotton candy. The scent undoubtedly blew in from Lake Erie — which was then a bouillabaisse of Lex Luthor chemicals and unimaginable garbage — and this scent mingled with the rust and asbestos and despair to create a smell that was new and unforgettable.
This was the indefinable smell of my childhood. it was the smell of losing.
Most people, I suspect, do not realize that Cleveland is actually in its second phase of losing. This current phase — which we can call the Heartbreak Phase — began on January 11, 1987, three days after my 20th birthday. This was the beginning of adulthood. You can, if you want, pinpoint the precise moment when everything Cleveland changed. It was on third down and 18, with Cleveland leading Denver by a touchdown. The wind howled, and the people in Cleveland Municipal Stadium drank schnapps and huddled close and made a wailing sound that could only come from frozen men and women who had known disappointment. Up to that very instant, we all believed Cleveland could win. We had no idea we were rooting, passionately, for WIle E Coyote.
John Elway zipped a 20-yard pass to Mark Jackson, and this led to culmination of The Drive (2), which led to The Fumble (3), which led to Michael Jordan soaring over Craig Ehlo (4), which led to the bitter face of Bill Belichick in his pre-genius period (5), which led to the Browns skipping town (6), which led to the Indians losing to Atlanta in the one freaking World Series the Braves decided not to choke (7), which led to Jose Mesa and Tony Fernandez and that horrifying Game 7 (8), which led to a return of some new team wearing Jim Brown’s uniform (9), which led to the LeBron Sweep (10), which led to present day and the eventual high crime of LeBron himself wearing that Yankees hat to an Indians playoff game.
This is the phase people talk about, but the losing actually has a beginning. It wasn’t until Elway came along that we Clevelanders realized that we were cursed. Until then, we thought our teams just sucked. It’s a crucial distinction. Norv Turner sucks. Marty Schottenheimer is cursed. The first makes you want to throw a brick at something. The second makes you wish someone would throw a brick at you. Two very different feelings.
* * *
When I was 5 and wandered into sports consciousness in Cleveland — this would be 1972 — Cleveland still saw itself as a winning sports town that had fallen out of fighting shape, a once brilliant ex-jock with a beer belly. In the 1950s, the Cleveland Browns had played in the NFL Championship Game seven times. They had won the championship game in 1964, they had reached the championship again in 1965. Everyone in 1972 still remembered exactly what it was like to watch Jim Brown. The Indians were also good most of the 1950s, but were generally shut out by the Stengel-Mantle Yankees. They were erratic but reasonably interesting in the 1960s. The great and crabby Bob Feller still bounced around town and spoke to Optimist clubs and Little League banquets. He was available for Bar Mitzvahs.
The Cleveland NBA team was brand new, and nobody knew what to think of them yet. There had been one of those never-a-good-idea newspaper nickname contests, and the team was eventually named “Cavaliers†after those dashing well-dressed supporters of King Charles I in the English Civil War of 1600. There is no explanation how this name won, in large part because, seriously, what explanation could possibly answer that question? The first Cavaliers logo was an odd drawing of one the English dandies (I always suspected it was Jacob Astley, but that’s just me, I could be wrong, I don’t want to start a bar fight with you Henry Wilmot fans) brandishing his sword toward a basketball roughly the color of yellow snow, the color being the only authentic Cleveland item in the logo.
In any case, there was no sense of sports doom in Cleveland then. True, the Indians had just lost 100 games, the Browns were slowly, but steadily, sinking into the abyss, and the Cavaliers had a drawing of the fourth musketeer on their jerseys. The irrepressible feeling, though, was that the city was mired in a minor and temporary sports slump (and a minor and temporary economic slump as well) but it was only that, a slump, and the sun would rise again. That feeling of hope was best described by a hauntingly beautiful jingle that used to play on a Channel 5 commercial throughout my youth.
The best things in life are right here in Cleveland
From the Playhouse to the Karamu (11)
From the parks to the Cleveland zoo
We’re a big league city with little leagues too!
University Circle, Blossom and the Heights
Make it clear! Very clear!
That Cleveland’s a great place to live!
‘Cause all the best things in life are here! (12)
I would say it wasn’t until about 1977 that we, as a city, realized that no, this wasn’t just a minor dip for Cleveland. We had, rather unexpectedly (at least it seemed unexpected to me as a child) become the nation’s punch line. The Cuyahoga River caught fire in 1969, Lake Erie was specifically called out in Dr. Seuss’ odd environmental book “The Lorax†(the Lake Erie reference was later taken out), the mayor’s hair caught fire, the banks withdrew credit from the city. I knew things were bad when Cleveland was dissed on television show “One Day at a Time.†In this scene, Schneider the super, for reasons that defy memory and reason, ended up locked in a room with a Soviet dissident.
Schneider: “So what is it like in Siberia.â€
Dissident: “It is cold and terrible place.â€
Schneider: “Oh yeah, we have Cleveland.â€
By 1980, when I was 13, the Browns gave us our one hope. Everything else was dismal. The weather. The gas lines. The roads. The Indians were terrible and more or less bankrupt. The Cavaliers were still wearing those horrendous uniforms, and they were owned by the late Ted Stepien, a key figure of my childhood if for no other reason than he allowed me to see a halftime show called “Fat Guy (Eating Beer Cans).
* * *
My favorite Ted Stepien moment had to be the interview he did after he decided to drop softballs from the top of the Terminal Tower, the tallest building in Cleveland. He did this, allegedly, to promote the pro softball league that he had created (13), but I always suspected that he just wanted to see what would happen if he dropped softballs from the top of the Terminal Tower.
Here’s what happened: He broke a woman’s wrist, broke a windshield and grazed another guy’s shoulder. It was like a horror movie. Softball Attack! Afterward, they interviewed him, and he had this great sheepish look on his face that said, so clearly, â€Um, I guess that was kind of a dumb idea.“
Stepien, from what I could tell, was not a bad guy. He was not a good guy, but not bad. He was an advertising man from Pittsburgh who had once been a good high school basketball player, and from my perspective he mainly seemed surprised that he had actually made enough money to own his own team. He was a fan at heart, which sounds like a good thing for an owner to be, but it really isn’t. Fans think they know. Stepien was sure he knew. And he knew absolutely nothing.
He also had a huge ego, which completed the picture of incompetence. One of the first things he did was fire Cleveland icon Joe Tait — the greatest basketball announcer I have ever heard — because Tait had the audacity to publicly question a couple of the obviously bad Stepien’ ownership moves. Tait (I can still hear him now, â€The line, the lane, the shot, it drops.“ â€Pass outside to Bingo Smith, top of the key, it’s the Bingo Rainbow, and it’s good!“) eventually returned, but not before Stepien had made the Cavaliers the all-time joke in sports.
Here’s how bad Ted Stepien was an owner: As soon as he became owner, he hired Bill Musselman to be the coach. Musselman was a generally successful but indisputably insane coach (14) who once said that defeat is worse than death. His drawing card was defense — his team at Ashland University once allowed teams 33 points per game — which you might recall wasn’t an especially important feature of early 1980s NBA basketball. The Cavaliers, a motley bunch anyway, could not get it, and they won only 25 of Musselman’s first 71 games. Stepien fired him, which was somewhat more humane than dropping him from the top of the Terminal Tower (though you suspect Musselman would have preferred that).
Here’s the thing: The very next year, Stepien had Chuck Daly as his coach. So he fired Daly and hired Musselman BACK. When asked why, he said (according to Terry Pluto): â€Bill won 25 games with a team of Mike Bratz, Roger Phegley, Mike Mitchell, Bill Laimbeer and, really, no bench.“ Musselman won two of 23 games and was canned again.
Of course, Stepien became famous for his extraordinarily bad trades. The NBA still has the remrakable â€Stepien Rule“ which prevents teams from trading their first round pick in back-to-back years. Stepien traded away so many high draft picks from 1982-1985 — the league office finally had to step in and announce that it would need to approve all Cleveland trades. Before they did that, though, Stepien traded four of his high picks to the Dallas Mavericks, who apparently would have someone manning the phones more or less 24 hours a day just in case Stepien called. He also traded Bill Laimbeer and James Edwards to Detroit, where they won a championship for Chuck Daly, the man Stepien had called, â€Not a proven NBA coach“ just before firing him.
One year, I remember Stepien trying to talk a 50-year old Wilt Chamberlain out of retirement.
Stepien did, however, keep the Cavaliers somewhat solvent, and he did hire Fat Guy (Eating Beer Cans) who was, yeah, a fat guy who ate beer cans. I seem to recall that the guy wanted to be known as â€Superfan“ (though his only known superpower was his uncanny ability to eat aluminum, which might be tough to build a series around). He would move around the Richfield Arena (another genius move — the Cavs played at an arena in the middle of nowhere between Cleveland and Akron), and he ate beer cans to the confusion and eventual boredom of the 432 people who would go to Cavs games in those years. I mean how many times could you see a man eat a beer can? Stepien did hire cheerleaders called the Teddy Bears, who remain to this day the closest thing to actual strippers to perform at an NBA game. And so went my Cleveland childhood.
* * *
In 1977, the Cleveland Indians did not exactly make reservations in hotels. Instead, they would arrive in town, and the team bus would drive around and stop at different hotels until they found one where the team’s credit was still good. This would sometimes take two or three stops.
When I heard this shocking bit of news from several members of that team, a number of things began to make sense. There was always something slightly pathetic about cheering for the Indians … rooting for them always felt a little bit like rooting for a doomed restaurant in a bad location that never had any people in it. The newspaper reports sometimes hinted that the Indians were on the brink of collapse, that they were looking perhaps at moving to another city, that the owners were really, really broke. But I believe now they kept the worst from us because, hey, it was bad enough being a Cleveland fan.
For instance: The team really did refuse to put air conditioners in the home clubhouse … the movie â€Major League“ was much more of a documentary than any of us knew at the time.
One year, pitcher Wayne Garland — who actually signed a big-money free agent offer with Cleveland during those dark years — bought air conditioners for everyone in the clubhouse. His pungent explanation years later: â€It was bleeping hot.“ Ownership tried to fine him for putting in those air conditioners.
Nothing made sense with those Indians teams. It wasn’t that they were comically bad (for much of my childhood, they hovered somewhere close to .500, though, of course, they were never good) but the entire experience was comical. No matter where you sat in Cleveland Municipal Stadium, your view was blocked by a metal beam. It was architectural genius. I.M. Pei could not have done better. And so you would have to lean back and forth all game long, back and forth, back and forth, like people praying at the Wailing Wall.
Then, you had to keep moving because it was cold inside Cleveland Municipal Stadium. It could be July, it could be 98 degrees everywhere else including the stadium parking lot, but once inside, the wind kicked up off the lake, and it would instantly drop to 12-degrees below zero. Then, the wind would dissipate, and the sun would blaze down, and it would be 117 degrees. Then the wind kicked up again. All around you could see rust and dripping asbestos and exposed and cut wires that would occasionally spark. The floor stuck like fly paper. It would have been a good place to interrogate people.
Who could enjoy a game in this atmosphere? Real Clevelanders. They would wear short-sleeve shirts and laugh at the shivering tourists. These were tough men and women, they had to be tough, they had STAYED in Cleveland even as hundreds of thousands fled the city throughout the 1970s for places South and West where the potholes did not eat cars and the sun occasionally burst through the smoke and the city’s No. 1 resource was not brown slush. I loved these people who stayed. Still do. Real Clevelanders. They all seemed to have incomprehensible jobs like bending refrigerators or blowing the crushing carburetors into dust with their bare hands. They lived hard lives. They drank beer that smelled like gasoline out of wax paper cups, and they smoked Marlboros and Kents without filters, and would take a nip now and again from a flask containing schnapps powerful enough to burn through metal, and they believed that this time, definitely this time, Rick Manning would come through.
We all loved Indians center fielder Rick Manning (still do) and I figure that this is because there always seemed this chance that he would, like the city itself, emerge into superstardom. Manning was fast, and handsome, and he seemed big enough to hit with a little power, and he played the game hard, and he won a Gold Glove his second year … it always seemed possible that he would turn into Duke Snider or Fred Lynn or someone heroic. Unfortunately, he wore No. 43, and that’s what he would do too often, it was 4-3, 4-3, all day long. He made 821 outs to second base in his career, and while I don’t know if this is a lot compared to other players, I’ll bet I saw 700 of them.
Duane Kuiper was my personal hero because of the way he dived for every ground ball, including those hit to third base. But there were any number of classic characters. Rico Carty would not slide because he kept his wallet in his back pocket (â€I don’t trust nobody,“ he would say). Manager Frank Robinson was utterly despised by everybody on the team and once got into a still legendary fight with the immense Jim Bibby. Third baseman Buddy Bell was tougher than steel wool and he once played on a broken toe by cutting open his shoe and painting his sock red. And so on. To a kid, these players always seemed on the brink of doing something spectacular. The Indians from 1972 to 1993 never once finished higher than fourth place.
And unlike the tough refrigerator-benders at the ballpark, most people in Cleveland stayed away then. They saw the Indians as just another thing in the city to be embarrassed about. I remember once going to Cedar Point (â€The Amazement Park!“) and being on the boat ride that the floated to Western World. Suddenly we passed a tribe of wild Natives who were shooting at us, and the guide said, â€Oh, don’t worry, those are Cleveland Indians, and they can’t hit anything.“ The laughter on the boat was loud and pained.
* * *
Whenever something even slightly positive happened, we in Cleveland tended to overreact. In 1976, for instance, the Cavaliers made a rather unlikely run to the Eastern Conference finals, where they were unceremoniously booted by the unquenchable Boston Celtics in six games. It was a nice story. In Cleveland we refer to it, even now, as â€The Miracle of Richfield.“
In 1980, a 25-year-old Indians rookie named Joe Charboneau hit 23 home runs and won the Rookie of the Year and, as a nice bonus, could open beer bottles with his eye socket. A great little story. We called him Super Joe Charboneau and determined that he deserved his own song:
Who’s the newest guy in town?
Go Joe Charboneau
Turns the ballpark upside down
Go Joe Charboneau
Super Joe hurt his back and only played 70 more agony-filled games, though I’m told he would later would be seen playing softball around town.
So, this might give you an idea just how important the 1980 Cleveland Browns were to us. They remain the only legitimate title contender of my childhood. I’m not certain, looking back, how legitimate they really were. The defense was leaky and led by the still insane but now aging Lyle Alzado, who would simply change the coach’s plays whenever the mood struck him. The coach, Sam Rutigliano, was a likable but certifiable son of Brooklyn immigrants who used to say very uncoach-like things like, â€Running the football is boring.“ The quarterback was a Southern California guy named Brian Sipe who had such a weak arm that when he threw the ball into the wind, it would sometimes come back to him. The Browns also had a straight-on kicker named Don Cockroft, and he had a herniated disc, which meant that pretty much any field goal longer than 13 yards was an adventure.
What they did have, though, was a little bit of magic. We called them the Kardiac Kids — I never liked that cute spelling of Kardiac, that seemed very un-Cleveland like — and they had this uncanny knack for winning (and losing) games in the final seconds. The Browns went 11-5 in 1980, and they won nine of those by a touchdown or less. They were exactly what we needed in Cleveland, a thrilling team in orange pants that passed the ball all over the field and somehow won in the end. We gave our hearts to them totally. We were sure that they were charmed. We were sure that something good was finally going to happen to us. We felt sure that we deserved that.
Then the Browns played Oakland on a brutally cold day in Cleveland, and it all came crashing down. Don Cockroft, predictably, missed two field goals and had an extra point blocked. Brian Sipe’s passes fluttered in the wind (he was intercepted three times). Still, we believed, we believed until the end, and sure enough the Browns moved the ball deep into Oakland territory, final seconds of the game, and that’s when Sam Rutigliano called Red Right 88 and told Sipe that if it wasn’t there, if the receiver wasn’t open, he was to throw the ball into Lake Erie, and Cockroft would try once more to kick the field goal.
It wasn’t there. Sipe threw the ball instead into the arms of Oakland defensive back Mike Davis.
Ali said that the Thrilla in Manilla was the closest thing he ever felt to dying. That was the sports feeling an entire city felt when that last pass quivered into the Lake Erie wind and died. You could feel the ground sink three inches when Sipe threw that interception. It was only sports, but it was all we had. There would be a whole lot of heartbreak after that in Cleveland — Drive, Fumble, Jordan, Mesa. But to me that moment remains. That was the moment that told me, life is not like the movies, cartoons or wrestling matches. The good guys lose.
â€I love you Brian,“ Rutigliano said to Sipe as he came off the field.
* * *
So that’s what it has been like in Cleveland. Comedy. Tragedy. Stupidity. Agony. Right now, I am watching Cleveland lose to Boston 10-3 in the first game of the American League Championship Series, and I realize that at this point, as a Clevelander, after 40 years, you come to know the awful truth. Pain’s coming.
And that’s why LeBron’s hat mattered. Because even if he really does love the Yankees, even if he is secretly related to Mickey Mantle, even if George Steinbrenner paid his family’s mortgage during hard times, even if his great grandfather handed him a Babe Ruth autographed baseball on his deathbed — he still should know better. The Yankees have won a lot. The Yankees will win again. Cleveland’s a great place to live. ‘Cuz the best things in life are here.
* * *
Footnotes:
(1) t should be noted that loyalty was ESPECIALLY true in Cleveland in the 1970s. Here’s my opinion why: I think people in the pre-ESPN, NFL Ticket, MLB.com mosaic days chose their sports teams based on three main criteria:
1. Geography.
2. Media access.
3. Birthright.
Geography is obvious; you chose the team in your town. Media access is connected, but a little bit different. In Charlotte, N.C. — before the Carolina Panthers came to town — most people were either Atlanta Falcons fans or Washington Redskins fans, and this is because those were the teams on television pretty much every week. There are Yankees fans all over America (and Cardinals fans all over the Midwest) because that’s who they saw on television and heard on the radio.
The third reason, birthright, comes down to the simple truth that kids generally root for their parents team.
Well, if you grew up in Cleveland, you were hammered by all three reasons. There was a very strong geographical connection to the city; unlike other places I’ve seen, in Cleveland it didn’t matter if you were from South Euclid, Chagrin Falls, Chardon, University Heights or Chagrin. Someone asked you were you were from, you said: Cleveland.
The media access was strong too … I don’t recall reading much about other teams in the local papers. And of course there was no Internet surfing, no SportsCenter highlights, no expanded box scores, no nothing. I suppose you COULD have been an Orioles or Rams fan in Cleveland, but it would not have been easy.
The third, birthright, is especially key in Cleveland. As far as I knew, everybody’s father rooted for Cleveland teams. The reason now is obvious: Nobody was moving TO Cleveland in the 1970s. People were only moving away. In Charlotte, Atlanta, Phoenix, places like that, you could meet 100 people, and they would be from 85 different cities, and maybe 10 percent would be natives. Maybe. In Cleveland, everyone was a native or they had recently arrived (like my parents) from some place like Minsk or Lublin, which did not have a baseball team.
(2) The Drive represents the 98-yard drive, final minutes drive that Denver quarterback John Elway led against Cleveland in the 1987 AFC Championship Game. It was a torturous series of plays — the Browns were leading by a touchdown and needed only to keep the Broncos out of the end zone to go to their first Super Bowl. They did not stop him, which not only created heartbreak in Cleveland, but it also launched the heroic career of Elway, who would prove to be persistent pain in Cleveland’s neck (not to mention Kansas City).
(3) The Fumble represents the last-minute fumble of Cleveland Ernest Byner just as he was about to go into the end zone to tie Denver in the 1988 AFC Championship Game. The Browns had trailed all game … what hurt most is that Byner had played heroically all game, and at first glance he appeared to score the tying touchdown. So for a fan it sounded like this: â€YES! YES! WAIT! NO! NO! NOOOOOOO!“
(4) The Cavaliers led Chicago by a point in the final seconds of their clinching playoff game when Michael Jordan set off his career of heroics by getting the in-bounds pass, rising for his jump shot, hanging in the air long enough to allow his defender Craig Ehlo to jump and then fall back to earth, and then making the winning shot. Until that instant, Cleveland and Chicago seemed to be very similar teams. After that instant, Chicago won six NBA titles while Cleveland, naturally, won zero.
(5) Before Bill Belichick became the super-genius of sports as coach of New England, he was a disastrous and bitter coach in Cleveland. He ran the team much in the same way Richard Nixon ran the White House … I remember once going to work in the press box, which overlooked the practice field. About five minutes before practice started, a public relations person came in and, very theatrically, pulled down all the shades so that we would not be able to see practice. I have no problem with the concept — many coaches don’t allow reporters to see practice — it was the theatrics that was pure Belichick. The team did not win a single playoff game in Belichick’s tenure as Browns coach, and he also theatrically cut hometown hero, quarterback Bernie Kosar. When asked about the uproar, he said, â€I don’t care what people think.“ Good man.
(6) At the end of the 1994 season, longtime Browns owner Art Modell moved the Cleveland Browns to Baltimore, where they became the Ravens and, shortly thereafter, won the Super Bowl.
(7) In 1995, the Braves beat the Indians in the World Series. It remains the only World Series title during the Braves era of winning 14 division titles. They won when Tom Glavine threw a one-hit shutout in Game 6 without, as any Cleveland fan will tell you, throwing a single strike all game long.
(8) In 1997, Cleveland lost Game 7 of the World Series to Florida even though they went into the ninth inning with the lead. There were a whole herd of goats, starting with Jose Mesa, who gave up two hits and a sac fly in the ninth to allow the Marlins to tie the game. The Indians never came even close to scoring in the 10th or 11th innings. And in the bottom of the 11th, Bobby Bonilla singled, and then Craig Counsell hit a ground ball to Cleveland second baseman Tony Fernandez, who flat booted it. This eventually led to Edgar Renteria’s heart-crushing and run-scoring single the ended things.
(9) The Cleveland Browns returned in 1999 with the same uniforms, owners of their own history (this was supposed to placate Cleveland fans) but to me they have never been the same. I know many Cleveland fans are over the Modell move, and they feel the same about the new Browns as they did the old Browns. I’m just not one of these people. I can’t help it.
(10) In 2006, LeBron James almost singlehandedly led the Cavaliers to the NBA Finals, which electrified the city. Sadly, though, the Cavs were swept by San Antonio and the Spurs were so dominating, so overwhelming, so much better than Cleveland, it sort of took some of the fun out of it.
(11) The Karamu House was/is the nation’s oldest African American theater. I did not know that then either. I would have sworn they were singing “Katmandu.â€
(12) This was actually better than a later Cleveland public relations campaign, “New York may be the Big Apple, but Cleveland’s a plum.†After a while, in Cleveland, you just lost all sense of irony. … The shame of it is, I could not find a video of this commercial on You Tube, which has to be one of the few times that YouTube has let me down. Then again, it was not a complete failure; I did find this extraordinary Channel 5 commercial which, I believe, features more or less the same tune. It’s definitely the same orchestra. Enjoy!)
(13) This was the North American Softball League, a slow-pitch league that featured the greatest collection of beer guts in the history of sports (and this includes Charlie Kerfeld’s prime). The greatest player in my memory was, of course, a Clevelander, named Mighty Mike Macenko, who could be seen smoking a cigarette as he swung his bat in the on-deck circle. Mighty Mike hit like 583 home runs that season. I personally saw him hit eight home runs in a single game. He said that was an off-day.
(14) Musselman once was so angry about his team’s lack of passion that he played his starters all 48 minutes in an ABA game. Another time, he was so angry that a referee made bad calls that he chased the referee to his locker room and banged on the door. This may not sound like an unusual thing except the calls the referee made were IN HIS FAVOR. He kept screaming how the referee screwed the other coach, and it wasn’t right. You had to admire that sort of insanity.
What a great entry. I don’t even know how many times I laughed out loud. Thanks Joe. We all need something like that once in a while.
Its neat to see how sports losses are seen from the eyes of someone from a city outside my own. I can definitely relate.
Jesus, Joe — I come upstairs after the Tribe game to do some writing and find this. This. This is brilliant, and laugh-out-loud funny, and sad beyond the telling. You know what happens to me at those moments of sheer joy — when the Cavs put away the Pistons, when the Tribe buries the Yanks at Yankee Stadium to clinch the ALDS? I cry. I laugh and I cry. My throat and jaw ache the next day. I can’t tell the pain from the joy at this point; after so many years, they’re essentially the same thing.
But I wanted to say something about LeBron’s cap that I hadn’t thought of when I blogged about it over at esquire.com. Tom Brady didn’t show up at Fenway for a playoff opener against the Yanks wearing the NY on his head. He didn’t appear on camera sitting there at Fenway telling one and all he was rooting against the Sox. I know that Cleveland’s different and all, but if Brady had done that — or Bird, back in his day — I think it would’ve had serious and long-lived repercussions. And if a New York sports icon did likewise — if Ewing or Messier or Tiki Barber had gone to a playoff game against the Bosox at Yankee Stadium in a Boston cap, and told a national audience they were pulling for the Sox– well, they would’ve paid for it dearly, and not only in booing.
And here’s the Cleveland thing again: It wouldn’t have happened anyplace else. Brady, Bird, Ewing, etc. — neither those guys nor anyone else of that stature would EVER do such a thing. And not because those guys are simply old-school loyal and respectful, or any better-educated than LeBron, or less full of themselves, but because James really doesn’t care about his town, his franchise, and his fans. Maybe the same is true of 99.9% of all pro athletes — although that’s not my own exprience or opinion — but only LeBron is enough of a buffoon and a shitheel to put it out there, grinning for all the world to see.
I’m not sure that Cleveland really cares, either. The folks back home don’t expect (much less demand) respect or loyalty. They’re comfy with contempt. They expect to suffer and to lose — to lose face, to lose the game, and to lose the players they love. I can’t even blame them; I left in 1984. I care — I care a lot — but I don’t know what life there is truly like anymore. When I go back, it doesn’t look so good.
I myself have no doubt that LeBron is gone as soon as his current deal expires, and you know what? I don’t care, either. I’d prefer to see him go now, in fact. And if Cleveland fans had any dignity, the only sight they’d pay to witness is KIng James’s sorry ass hitting the road.
Longtime listener, first time caller…hey that only works in radio, but you get the idea.
Anyway, I remember watching the 1997 World Series Game 7 when I went away to college with a bunch of other Cleveland transplants at the local BW-3. In the bottom of the ninth with the Indians up 2-1, you knew who was legitimate longtime Indians fans and who started paying attention in 1995. The longtime fans knew not to get excited until the last out was recorded. The recent bandwagon jumpers were already celebrating. We all know what happened next.
I would be fine if this years Indians lost say, 4 games to 1 to the Red Sox or in the World Series, if the other team was convincingly better. But it never happens this way. I can see the Indians playing the Rockies in the World Series with John Elway sitting in the stands for game 7 and with the Tribe enjoying an 8 run lead going into the bottom of the ninth. The networks will be bored since the beloved Yankees aren’t in the World Series and the announcers can’t get super excited over Derek Jeter or memories of Mickey Mantle and they will drag out footage of the only other connection Cleveland and Denver have…the Drive. It’s the same footage they had to show over and over when the Broncos won the Super Bowl in 1997 and when Elway became enshrined in Canton. Oh and you can guarantee Fox will show this footage at least once if it is an Indians-Rockies World Series, even though it has nothing to do with anything. Then the Indians will proceed to give up back to back grand slams and then lose in the 11th inning. And yet another team that wasn’t even in existence when I started paying attention to sports and their long suffering fan base of 10 years can experience a title while we will once again wait until next year.
ClEEveland MuNIcipal StAAdium. We pick up with fiurst qwarter action.
BUT WAIT!
No one did halftime better than Cosell, and I always remember Cleveland Municipal Stadium (the full name) when I think about him versus Boomer, and others who have done it.
Quite a history.
I lived in Buffalo in 1987 and went to a Bills/Broncos game in Orchard Park (Elway and Kelly). Coldest I have ever been in my life. I had the best of the best on and still couldn’t keep warm. Turned in four different directions, and the wind was still in my face.
How many sports fans have had their hearts broken by a villain like Christian Laettner (after he had stepped on Aminu Timerlake. That’s what ticked us off!!!!!!! Where’s the justice? The guy went 10 for 10 from the field and 10 for 10 from the Free Throw Line!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! It’s not right.)?
And how about the Bluegrass Miracle? I was there for that one. Not even the Immaculate Reception was tipped three times!!!!!!!!!
What fans in this country have had two… two moments of such highs and lows in split seconds?
The Comeback Cats exercised one demon (no pun intended). Could another one be exercised tomorrow (it would take another Bluegrass Miracle)?
Awesome blog. Really enjoyed it.
Thank you, Joe.
Bravo, Joe! I’d already been hoping you’ll eventually do the 1977 Cleveland Indians book, just taking it on faith that it would be a good by the time you wrote it, but this is the first time I’ve had reason to believe they were genuinely fascinating on merit.
Perhaps my favorite “Baseball Abstract” essay — up there with “Revolution” and “Tanner’s Spring/ Tanner’s Fall”, anyway — was Bill James’s history of being a Kansas City baseball fan. You haven’t matched it here, mainly because your essays are long for unpaid blog work while he was actually getting money and filling a book ; I don’t know what The Drive or The Fumble are, the words “Jose Mesa” fill me with dread only because I’m a K.C. Royals fan, and you obviously have no obligation to fill me in (although I did buy “Soul of Baseball”!). Also, Bill was able to write his after the Royals won a World Series, a neat structural trick I guess I hope you’ll be able to employ soon. I mean, I’ve been following the Rockies with mild rooting interest for the last two seasons — I like the team they’ve been building — and I’ll root for the Rockies to crush the Red Sox any day, given the chance. But you’ve made it clear to me that Indians fans need the break, and they’ve got a nifty team of their own for once.
Bonus thanks: you inspired me to look up Wikipedia’s article about Cleveland’s bankruptcy, which inspired me in turn to learn more about Dennis Kucinich, the outgunned hero of the piece. Dennis, unlike say Ted Stepien, does seem to have a remarkable record for being right about things – my goodness. In person he comes across to me as a jerk who doesn’t listen to people, and I won’t vote for him, but I’m starting to understand why listening to people (fellow politicians in particular) came to seem a waste of time for him…
Joe, I moved to Cleveland in the mid 90s and will probably die here. I love this town, it’s people, and it’s baseball team with every fiber of my being, but I don’t think I ever understood this place. I couldn’t comprehend why folks would talk about this crummy football team while just a few blocks away a bunch of kids were sticking it to the richest city on earth. I didn’t understand the woe-is-us self-defeating attitude so pervasive here that was perfectly described in a conversation that I had with a corporate recruiter when she said “yeah, we don’t get natives to show out-of-towners around Cleveland because they never come through; we use folks who’ve only lived here for a few years to recruit.”
And it pissed me off to see us crap on ourselves the way we do.
But, after reading this, I understand this mentality a bit more, and dammit if I don’t love this town even more for it. Despite what we think, there will be a championship in this town sometime before the sun goes out. And when it happens, there will be joy unlike any seen anywhere else ever.
[...] LeBron’s hat… (JoePosnanski.com)Â In an admittedly self-absorbed entry, the great Joe Posnanski writes on his history of being a Cleveland sports fan and how LeBron’s donning of a Yankees cap last week an ALDS game last week at Jacobs Field might have an effect on the city’s fans. [...]
Great blog — I moved from Lakewood to Chicago in 1987, though my parents have lived their all their lives. Thanks for all the memories — especially “The Best Things In Life Are Here”! I can hear that tune in my head right now.
My Eric Musselman memory, I think (and I might be getting this wrong) has particular resonance for KU fans.
S. Alabama had a double-digit lead over Arizona with about 8 minutes to play. I was thrilled as I had them as an upset winner in my bracket. Of course, Musselman overcoached his team (I’m certainly no expert, but I think you get bad shots when you spend the entire 45 seconds not actually testing the other team’s defense sitting on a lead that another team can, in fact, eliminate) to sit on the lead.
The winner of that game? Arizona, the Bibby-Dickerson team that beat the team local fans were convinced was the KU team destined to go to win the title.
Then, according to Wikipedia, he did assistant coaching for the Rasheed Wallace-era Blazers, a team that lost a MASSIVE lead to the Lakers in LA (it was like 16-18 points to begin the 4th quarter) in an elimination game.
I’m a Cleveland boy, born in 1977 – my first real sports love was the ‘87 Tribe, followed closely by the Browns. I remember actually throwing up because I was crying so badly when Elway lead the f’n Broncos on The Drive. Next year, I expected the Browns to lose, and they came through for me.
I was in college during the ‘95 Indians playoff run, listening to the first round of games on a crappy alarm clock radio because my dorm room didn’t have cable. I’ve never had a sports experience like those playoffs, it seemed like the Tribe was a team of destiny. Everyone expected them to win. ‘97, on the other hand, felt like we kept waiting for the shoe to drop – nobody expected a title from that team.
My wife doesn’t understand the pain and agony caused by Cleveland sports, doesn’t understand why I expect to lose – maybe your article will help.
This is brilliant. Why on earth are you posting this on a blog instead of publishing it in the paper when the series goes back to Cleveland?
You might also be interested to know that in Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Cleveland was identified as being located over one of the mouths of hell.
What, no mention of the Cleveland Barons?
Great piece, Mr. Joe.
Geography and parental influence are powerful things. I grew up about halfway between Chicago and Detroit. My dad liked the Cubs, my mom liked the Tigers, my grandmother was a White Sox fan and nobody in my house gave a damn about football (although for some reason we all hated Notre Dame). I was a pretty screwed up baseball fan!
I do hope you’re working on that next book. I already have my check made out, pointed in the direction of the publisher…
Joe,
Great post. But Belicheck did win a playoff game in Cleveland. He beat the Patriots and Parcells.
I loved the part about the softball attack. Hilarious!
I’m no longer going to try to explain Cleveland sports to those that don’t understand.
With your permission, I’m just going to print out your post, carry it around in my wallet, and hand it — without comment — to anyone that asks.
Outstanding. Absolutely outstanding.
Joe – As you know by now, I’m from Boston originally, and I can honestly say that your description of the difference between knowing that your teams suck and knowing that your teams are cursed was pretty much the most accurate thing I’ve ever read on the subject. I must admit that I never fully bought into the whole “Curse” foolishness, but those thoughts certainly cross your mind in the moments immediately following such seminal disaterous moments as Bill Buckner’s error, Bucky Dent’s home run, Len Bias’ death, and Tony Eason’s career, and wanting someone throw a brick at you is an extremely accurate representation of the emotions felt in those moments. Kudos.
Also, thanks for the bit of nostalgia about Cedar Point. I lived in Ft. Wayne, Indiana for about three years as a kid, and since there was nowhere really fun to go in Ft. Wayne, our 6th grade class outing was to Cedar Point. There’s nothing quite like your first “long” trip without your parents tagging along, especially when you combine it with riding your first roller coaster, eating too much, and falling asleep on the bus on the way home as your friends take pictures, hide your hat and mock your snoring. Good times.
I finally set aside time (on my employer’s dime, of course) to read this entry, and I’m happy I did. The description of REAL Clevelanders is incredible. And I think I’m finally beginning to understand what it’s like for them.
I’m just a baseball fan. Growing up in northern California in the seventies and eighties meant one thing: you were a Niners fan, and your life was beautiful. I, however, couldn’t take to football – that was too easy. As a dedicated masochist, I must be a Giants fan. Maldonado’s catch. An earthquake. San Diego and Colorado teaming up to enable Atlanta’s epic 1993 drive. Florida’s two rent-a-championship teams. Willie Mays opening the bottle of champagne when we were still six outs away. Did you know that the Giants have led in each of their last nineteen postseason games?
So I think I understand the pain, just a little. I know I’m pulling for the Indians with all my might. You don’t want to know how that usually turns out.
“Sadly, though, the Cavs were swept by San Antonio and the Spurs were so dominating, so overwhelming, so much better than Cleveland, it sort of took some of the fun out of it.”
This article was the best. I can recall vividly each Browns debacle and I am much like the author with regard to the “new” Browns. I guess after all it isn’t just the laundry we root for. But I miss loving those Browns so much that even if they only won 1 game, if it was against Pittsburgh, it was a successful season. Perhaps in a future blog he can explain why I just can’t connect with the new team. The old Browns sucked too for long stretches….I just can’t figure it out.
I couldn’t understand some parts of this article , but I guess I just need to check some more resources regarding this, because it sounds interesting.
Excellent writing, Joe. Perfectly describes … well, pretty much everything about being a Cleveland fan during the last 30+ years. I was in the Dawg Pound for The Drive, and froze during Red Right 88, even though that was in our house in Akron (furnace broke, so we watched the game dressed like the fans at the game). My first Indians game (mid 70’s) had the Tribe down by one with 2 on in the ninth, only to have Joe Lis strike out to end it. I miss Municipal. Sort of. It was fun when there were 70,000+ fans. It was nice to be able to walk up to Gate A 5 minutes before game time and get lower box seats. And the hotdogs were out of this world. And it was nice sitting next to the third base dugout on May 15th, 1981. Easily my greatest baseball moment. (yes, I have the ticket stub).
Thank goodness for the Buckeyes in 2002. At least ONE team I root for actually won a championship!
Joe,
A friend of mine turned me on to the soul of baseball blog and I was an instant fan. Fast forward several months and he and I were talking about Wahoo, and he said I should read your other blog. Good story on Wahoo, I disagree, but your points are well-taken. However, this one really speaks to my heart. I have never, I repeat, never lived in Cleveland, but love them because my dad does. I grew up in Pittsburgh, and I have never once been able to stick it to them because the Browns don’t often beat the Steelers, and well, AL v. NL doesn’t count til October if you ask me. Your blog here has shown me what my dad suffered through as a Cleveland fan since he was born in 1948. I didn’t come along to care about sports til about ‘88 or ‘89, so I got some good years, but got glimpses and I remember ‘95 and ‘97 like it was yesterday. I think one heartbreak you left out was the strike of ‘94 because the Indians were on an incredible pace, and that was arguably their best team.
When the Browns left, I mourned, and grudgingly became a Steelers fan, and I share your feeling of not feeling quite right about the new Browns. I was happy when the Steelers won the Super Bowl two years ago, but now I feel like a football fan without a team. As a Notre Dame grad, I’m inclined to root for “the heart-throb” Brady Quinn when he gets his chance, but I’m stuck not knowing who to root for. I think Quinn is a quintessential Clevelander. A kid from Ohio who loves the Browns; college phenom, but left sitting all alone at the draft to go in the 20’s. Who from Cleveland couldn’t love a down-trodden kid like that. I love my Browns of old, and Bernie Kosar, but I also love the new Steelers and Jerome Bettis. I think I might be the most confused NFL fan ever as my two teams couldn’t be more bitter rivals. I’d like to personally thank Art Modell for that one.
At the least though, we do have the Browns back, and maybe some time we will regain what we lost for 4 years.
I’ll tell you, the only thing getting me through this Notre Dame football season are my Cleveland Indians. Your blog has given me a new appreciation for our struggle, and for all those who have lived in Cleveland all these years, and for this young man who is looking to moving there for residency. I love the “mistake on the lake,” my second home, where my grandparents lived in bedford and akron, and where i spent my summers in Sandusky – near the “amazement park.”
Thanks for giving us Cleveland fans this outlet!
Marvelous work, Joe.
Just one quick correction. Belichick did win a playoff game during his Cleveland years. I remember it well. It was after the 1994 season against my New England Patriots – 20-13. Bill stunning started Vinny Testeverde at Quarterback. We all laughed…until the end of the game.
Another note about Bill Musselman – he was the coach at the University of Minnesota when Dave Winfield and company stomped the Buckeyes in an on-court brawl in 1968.
From the Wikipedia entry on Luke Witte:
“In the Ohio State-Minnesota game, played at Minnesota on January 25, 1972, Ohio State led 50-44 with 36 seconds to go. Witte went for a layup but was fouled hard. Immediately following the foul, Minnesota player Corky Taylor extended an arm to help Witte up, then kneed Witte in the groin and punched him in the head. While on the floor, he was also kicked and stomped by Minnesota player Ron Behagen, knocking him unconscious.
What followed was an extended brawl that included fans leaving the stands and joining in. Witte’s teammate, Dave Merchant, attempted to come to his aid, but was struck in the face several times by Gopher Jim Brewer. Another Buckeye, Mark Wagar (currently the President of Empire BlueCross BlueShield in New York), was attacked from behind by Minnesota player — and future Major League Baseball Hall of Famer — Dave Winfield, who landed five punches into Wagar’s face.
Officials stopped the game, and awarded the Buckeyes a 50-44 victory, prompting Minnesota fans to boo and throw objects as Witte was carried from the floor. Hospitalized for several days, including 24 hours in intensive care, Witte’s injuries, which included 29 facial stitches and a scarred cornea, in the views of many permanently affected his career. In all, three Ohio State players were taken to hospitals.”
That’s the guy that Stepien hired to coach the Cavs.
Sorry – the brawl was in 1972.